The subtlest theft. Take a person's past, or their sense of being a separate self, and there's nothing left to organize a rebellion around.
6The Giver
Lois Lowry · 1993
All pain and all history offloaded onto one designated rememberer; everyone else lives in medicated Sameness. It's shelved as middle grade, and it's flatly terrifying as an adult. The moment that got me: Jonas is tossing an apple with a friend and it flashes, briefly, into something he has no word for, because his whole community sees no color. That's how Lowry reveals the theft, one apple mid-throw. And "release," the community's word for what happens to the old and the imperfect, sits in the same drawer as Ishiguro's "completing."
Pacing verdict: An afternoon, start to finish. The ambiguous ending has been starting arguments for thirty years and will start one in your house too.
7We
Yevgeny Zamyatin · written 1921
The source code, and the 1921 book from the opening line. Soviet censors refused to print it, so it reached readers first in English, in New York, in 1924. In OneState people have numbers instead of names and live in glass apartments; you may lower the blinds only for the state-scheduled intimacy hour, ticket required. The narrator D-503 is a true believer building a spaceship to export this happiness to other planets, and his diary falls apart in real time as an unauthorized woman teaches him to want things. The state's final cure is the Great Operation: surgical removal of the imagination. Orwell reviewed this book in 1946, three years before publishing 1984, and the receipts show.
Pacing verdict: Jagged, feverish diary fragments from a mathematician losing his faith. Strange for the first thirty pages, then it grabs. Short, too.